The similarities between the two organisations were striking, and these were most likely due to the shared traditions, values and modes of operations of a symphony orchestra organisation. There were some minor cultural differences evident between the two organisations, including the ways in which they dealt with player discipline, competition, language, and expectations; however, significant cultural differences were not evident from the data. While there were differences around resourcing and depth of talent pool, these differences seemed to be due to the differences between a state and a national youth orchestra, rather than any specific cultural factors. One important difference is the formal arrangement between the SNYO and the Ministry of Education (MoE) in Singapore. The SNYO is a National Project of Excellence recognised by the MoE as an official Co-Curricular Activity (CCA). This means that students who are studying in a MoE school, can have their participation in rehearsals, concerts and other activities count towards their CCA points (SNYO n.d.) No such recognition via a type of credit arrangement is provided to school-aged players for their participation in the TYO by the Department of Education Children and Young People (DECYP in Tasmania.
Key words and phrases that informed the development of this dimension include: 1. Similarities: Parents, balance, boundaries, prioritise, tradition, well-established, background; 2. Differences: Resourcing. cost, subsidy, professional, pressure, numbers, and pipeline. This dimension includes how participant groups speak about their organisation with regards to resourcing, culture, and key stakeholder attitudes and dispositions. Managers spoke about the fact that they noticed far more similarities than differences during their visits, these included the demands on them, their players and demands from parents. For players they speak about their relationship to the organisation and conductors / managers, often recalling situations where they felt well supported. For managers and conductors this was about how they support players through their pedagogic practices but was also sometimes about their own previous negative learning experiences and wanting to ensure player safety now.
This dimension has two components:
Singapore and Australia are both Asia-Pacific countries, yet their orchestras share a western music tradition. Both countries have well regarded youth orchestras enabling young musicians to play music at high levels in nurturing environments. Tasmanian Youth Orchestras (TYO) draws its players from within the state of Tasmania while the Singapore National Youth Orchestra (SNYO) draws its players from across the nation-state of Singapore. This is an important distinction as Kartomi (2007) indicates that, “Some national orchestras lie within the infrastructure of a professional orchestra” (p. 10). This is the case for the SNYO as it is part of the Singapore Symphony group which also manages the Singapore Symphony Orchestra (SNYO, n.d.). The implication is that the SNYO has easy access to a venue hall for rehearsals and a budget to pay for ongoing expenses (i.e., the transport of instruments to and from venues). This is in contrast to the TYO which is a “free-standing” orchestra (Kartomi, 2007, p. 5) and not able to draw upon the resources of their professional orchestra. Common to both orchestras, however, are their collaborations and performance opportunities with professional orchestras such as the Singapore Symphony Orchestra and Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra respectively (SNYO, n.d.; TYO Strategic Plan 2021-2024, n.d.). For example, players from both youth orchestras have opportunities to learn through structured sectionals and mentoring opportunities from professional musicians who are part of the Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra and Singapore Symphony Orchestra respectively.
Youth orchestras have their own mission statements that identify their overarching purpose, goals, and activities (Kartomi, 2007) and the TYO and SNYO are no different. A cursory glance at the websites for both orchestras reveals similar purposes and values. For example, the TYO states it “seeks to deliver programs of outstanding quality and benefit – increasing musical participation, providing pathways to professional careers and growing lifetime musicians and supporters of the arts. TYO’s programs provide musical pathways for a wide range of participants, from those new to ensemble music, through to accomplished youth musicians who are already experienced performers” (TYO, 2023). Similarly, the SNYO says its vision is “to inspire a lifelong love for music and a dedication to exceptional orchestral performance … [Its mission is] … through the playing of orchestras music, we nurture future generations of musicians and build a vibrant music community for Singapore” (SNYO, n.d.).
Orchestral leaders (managers, board members, conductors, players, and tutors) create the organisational and educational circumstances in which young musicians can thrive. The writing on leadership within orchestras has shown that managers and conductors play distinctive yet complementary roles. While conductors tend to be responsible for the artistic side of operations such as programming, the repertoire, and auditioning, managers are responsible for the day-today activities such as rehearsal scheduling, administrative operations, budgeting, transporting of instruments (Cray & Inglis, 2011; Salvaggio, 2023; Symphona, n.d.). For players under 18 years of age, communicating with parents and occasionally dealing with parent concerns about their child, is a responsibility of managers. Both managers and conductors work together to support players’ musical skills as well as their self-regulation skills, and overall wellbeing (Pang, 2016).
Cray, D., & Inglis, L. (2011). Strategic decision making in arts organizations. The Journal of Arts Management, Law, and Society, 41(2): 84-102. https://doi.org.1080/10632921.2011.573444
Kartomi, M. (2007). Youth orchestras in the global scene. Australasian Music Research, 9, 1-26.
Pang, S.Y. (2016). The youth orchestra experience and development of 21st century competencies.” In S. Ning Kan & B. Soong (Eds), Thinking, learning and training. Siew Ning Kan and Benson Soong.
Salvaggio, S. A. (2023). Orchestra management in practice. Taylor and Francis.
Singapore National Youth Orchestra. (n.d.). SNYO about us. Retrieved April 30, 2024, from https://www.snyo.org.sg/overview
Symphona. (n.d.). The vital role of orchestral managers. Retrieved March 20, 2024, from https://symphona.app/blog/vital-role-of-orchestral-managers/
Tasmanian Youth Orchestras. (n.d.). Tasmanian Youth Orchestras: Strategic plan 2021-2024. Retrieved April 30, 2024, from https://www.tyo.org.au/_files/ugd/a793a8_3093ab22b20d4b22b09c7aa1eb9e047f.pdf
Tasmanian Youth Orchestras. (2023). About us. Retrieved April 30, 2024 from https://www.tyo.org.au
Lydia (Manager): I think one of the things that's really evident is that there are more similarities than differences and that speaks to the consistent tradition of youth orchestras globally. You know we all do a fairly similar thing[s] and we all have a fairly similar purpose and orchestral practice has a lot of well-established processes and a lot of well-established traditions.
Lydia (Manager): Similarly, Tania, like me, feels the concert programs are a key medium for stewarding a close connection between the organisation and the audience, so she does them herself to ensure clarity of message and quality outputs.
Lydia (Manager): It’s testament to the traditions and heritage of youth orchestral training that…rehearsals at the orchestra are not as different as you might expect. The basic structure and process of the…rehearsals is very much as it is at the orchestra.
Tania (Manager): Lydia and I think alike, have pretty similar working styles that's good and it's also not so good. Because we really think in terms of values. In terms of work style, ethics, we share many, many similar views and perspectives and there are quite a few things that it's a little bit uncanny I think. Everything that we've talked about, pretty much 80% of the time, we are in agreement on those issues.
Lydia (Manager): … it's really evident that youth orchestra leadership is a different gig to leading a symphony or even leading another type of community music organization. Youth orchestras have their own character and they have their own traditions and heritage and that's been really well illustrated by this trip [to Singapore] more than I had perhaps expected. We kind of occupy this liminal space where we're not professional but certainly not amateur either. Certainly our surrounding practice is professional, so we need to service the youth orchestra to the same standard that we would service a professional orchestra
Lydia (Manager): … We both have staffing insecurity. When you only have resourcing sufficient for casual staffing it’s a risk as casuals don’t have to accept shifts. It then falls on the leader to pick up the slack and you know, it was interesting to see that the morning after a concert…it was backing up into auditions. And I frequently do the same thing.
Vicky (Manager): With this youth orchestra organization, at this point of time, any of our positions are kind of like how long is a piece of string. It's just how much we're willing to put into it. There's always stuff to do, so I've become quite good I think at just drawing a line and saying, I'm just gonna stop there. You’ve just got to do the things that are the most important and constantly reassessing what's the most important, now and tomorrow….
Lydia (Manager): Tania’s comments on the frustrations of dealing with bureaucracy while also trying to lead an organisation were sadly all too familiar. As organisational heads, Tania and I are expected to position and carry ourselves as leaders within our sector – but we absolutely do not have the resourcing that comes with leadership roles in private sector organisations, or even larger arts NFPs [not for profits].
Lydia (Manager): Kids. Seriously, the young people, I mean obviously there are cultural differences but largely you know teenagers are teenagers. The teenagers here are particularly focused and then particularly well prepared, but there is still a very recognizable teenage dynamic and that's one of the things that sets us apart from a professional symphony orchestra, because there is an educational component and we are dealing with people who are in a very important development stage of their lives. We need to be willing to challenge them because that's one of the reasons they come to us, but we also need to be mindful that they are at a development phase and work with that.
Kyle (Conductor): Probably just all the competing commitments that children have in their week. You know, when I grew up, probably youth orchestra was my one major co-curricular, whereas these days I think people are spread so thin to do so many different things as well as you know, keep up on all the social media and everything else.
Samantha (Manager): … a good part of my work will also entail chorister and parent management. Yes, parent management is a big part of that, because well, I've got 180 kids, you know…obviously my work is not only managing, it's managing the parents as well, and of course, all the inquiries that come in.
Tania (Manager): … we do have one parent…the child is [a] male…player and 15 and the mother insisted on coming up to the rehearsal studio with him every single time. Every time we tell her she's not supposed to come up because, particularly during the COVID period as we want to reduce any kind of interaction so only the child comes into the building…She still does it. I've seen her but I've never actually managed to speak to her before she gets out.
Martin (Manager): We have to explain to the parent…that because the parts are limited and because of the challenges of finding orchestra pieces that have sufficient percussion parts. So it became difficult to ensure everybody gets assigned a part.
Kent (Conductor): Rehearsing a professional orchestra is a little bit easier in the sense that they are all adults, and you know in a youth orchestra setting, their parents are outside, thank god I don’t have to deal with them.
Liam (Player): … one of the greatest thing why I wanted to join the orchestra was because of the individual tuition scheme that they have.
Tania (Manager): I'm really amazed that the orchestra does not have that one rehearsal venue, that they rehearse out of so many different spaces in the space of a day. It is very, very, challenging when you need to, you know sort of pack your van and get set up bump into a space and then after that clear out and do this week after week.
Lydia (Manager): IF ONLY we could have the luxury of four evenings in the concert hall for pre-concert rehearsals and soundchecks. Wow. This is brilliant for the players and the team – it gives the players time to get used to the hall environment and the specific sound of the venue; and the team can be well settled with everything in place.
Lydia (Manager): It absolutely helps that the orchestra has a long tail of excellent applicants ready to come in at a moment’s notice if a player is missing too many rehearsals – we don’t have this luxury at our organisation. But even so, the difference in approach is quite pronounced
The collaborative/shared nature of youth orchestra leadership between conductors and managers was particularly evident in these data. Some conductors thought it was important to be aware of the many calls on players’ time for example. There was a sense of appreciation for the role played by managers in working with parents, enabling conductors to focus on their ensembles.
Did not feature in this dimension.
Managers were very well represented in this dimension. A real feature was the shared traditions and operational routines of running youth orchestras, and despite some minor cultural differences around engagement, the similarities they noticed about their players. There were considerable differences between the two ensembles however in respect of scale and resources, such as venues and staffing, yet these can be understood as economies of scale due to the differences between a national and a state organisation. Also of note, again to do with different levels of the two organisations, is the depth of the talent pool open to each organisation, which is also probably to with population size. This had repercussions for the extent to which policies around attendance for example were applied in practice.