Key words and phrases that informed the development of this dimension included: women, girls, leadership, diversity, gender, talent, capability, administration, conductor, tutor, maternal, and male. References coded to this theme were specifically around female leadership. There was a mixed bag of responses including clearly gendered biases and instrument selection, along with the notion that female leadership is more common now than in the past and particularly in the Arts and the Not-for-Profit Sector (NFPS).
This dimension includes how participant groups speak about their perceptions of gender and leadership. It is worth noting that this was by far the least represented of the four dimensions.
This dimension has five components. Two of the components were quite small with only one reference being made to the component by a participant. The components are:
In history, leadership has been viewed as the domain of men (Coleman, 2003) even though women have been leaders in and of their families, communities, and nations (Klenke, 1996). There is a structural inequality evident in the arts and in arts leadership. As Caust (2018) writes “women are the major consumers of most arts practices, yet they are generally less visible than men in arts leadership roles. Many major arts organizations still tend to be led by men and, with a few exceptions, the artistic leadership of many artforms is still dominated by men” (p. 40). This is certainly true in professional music organisations such as orchestras. In some ways women’s success in arts leadership roles seems to be culturally predetermined by gendered bias, as Caust (2018) writes “the challenge is that whichever style a female leader exhibits, they are still likely to be perceived as ‘ineffective’ or ‘wrong’” (p. 41). This bias is likewise reflected in salaries for female arts leaders, Caust writes that “when women reach senior leadership roles in the arts sectors, it seems likely that their salaries will be different from those of their male colleagues” (2018, p. 42).
In the world of classical music up until the 20th century, well-known conductors were men. Although recent decades have seen more women taking to the podium, women conductors continue to be under-represented in this male dominated profession. The gendered role of the conductor has remained unchallenged for centuries, and is rooted in patriarchy, as Bartleet (2008) writes “women conductors' inescapable difference from the male norm defines them as Other; disruptive figures that challenges dominant social and professional norms with their presence on the podium” (p. 6). In reference to the New York Philharmonic, the London Symphony Orchestra and the Sydney Symphony Orchestra Caust writes that “the gender of their resident conductors is overwhelmingly male. There are three designated conductors at the NYP (all male), seven designated conductors at the LSO (six out of seven are male) and two principal conductors at the SSO (both male). The one female conductor represented in any of the orchestras is a trainee conductor attached to the LSO. Female conductors are still the rare exception” (p. 43). According to the Royal Philharmonic Society (2023):
only five women conductors had titled roles amid the several hundred conductors on the staff of professional British orchestras. Furthermore, as at January 2023, only 52 of the 463 conductors represented by British agents were female. While that 11.2% is better than the 9% we recorded in 2020 and 5.5% in 2017, it is still a long way from equality. (para 2)
Women conductors are easily identifiable since they do not make up the critical mass. Some examples are provided here. Marin Alsop became America’s first music director in 2007 and this was of the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra (Hernandez, n.d.). Australia’s most famous female conductor is Simone Young who has been Chief Conductor of the Sydney Symphony Orchestra since 2019. As a 25 year old, she became the first woman and youngest person to be appointed as resident conductor for Opera Australia. Over 30 years ago, she was the first woman to conduct the Vienna State Opera and then the Vienna Philharmonic in 2005 (Freeland, 2023).
According to Vivien Goh, former conductor of the Singapore Youth Orchestra, notable Asian female conductors are Helen Quach from Vietnam, Yip Wing-sie from Hong Kong, and Wang Ya-Hui from Taiwan (Goh in Lim, 2023). Taking the Singapore Symphony Orchestra as an example, there are only two female conductors (out of seven) associated with the orchestra. One is Wong Lai Foon, Choirmaster of the Singapore Symphony’s Children Youth Choirs, and the other is an Assistant Chorale Conductor, Ellissa Sayampanathan (Singapore Symphony Orchestra, 2024).
Drawing on historical and contemporary examples, Hamer (2019) identifies several gender specific issues that help to explain the under-representation of women and aspiring women conductors in the world of orchestral conducting. Among these include the point that conducting is deemed a profession better suited to men; the conflicting demands of family and a career given the demanding nature of being a conductor; gender-based stereotypes about women conductors such as they may not be able to maintain discipline of orchestra players; and a lack of role models and mentors to support their development (Hamer, 2019). Similar to Hamer’s findings, Lazarou’s (2016) qualitative interviews with women conductors from the United Kingdom and media content analysis of data from online newspapers, magazines, and internet articles regarding women conductors, found evidence of gender bias and discrimination against women conductors; that conducting as a “male” tradition has excluded women from a variety of learning opportunities; and women face particular difficulties when trying to balance work with a career. These obstacles are ones that have been identified in the wider research and literature regarding women wishing to enter senior leadership positions (Gull, 2019; Morrison et al., 1987).
Given that leadership remains male dominated in the cultural industries (Scharff, 2018) and in particular orchestral conducting (Caust, 2018; Hamer, 2019; Lazarou, 2016; Watson, 2023), the gendered dimensions of leadership demand more examination (Nash et al., 2017). While youth orchestras rarely exhibit the gender inequities in elite professional symphony orchestras (Sergeant & Himonides, 2019), they are important training grounds for those with aspirations for a professional orchestral career, and good models of gender balanced leadership may enable future generations to avoid the allegations of sexism in the orchestral sector (Kiek, 2012).
Bartleet, B. L. (2008). You’re a woman and our orchestra just won’t have you: The politics of otherness in the conducting profession, Hecate 34(1), 6 – 23.
Caust, J. (2018). Arts leadership in contemporary contexts. Routledge.
Coleman, M. (1993). Gender and the orthodoxies of leadership. School Leadership & Management 23(3), 325–339. https://doi.org/10.1080/1363243032000112810
Freeland, A. (2023, March 21).ABC documentary knowing the score charts Simone Young’s meteoric rise to become one of the world's top conductors. ABC News. Retrieved April 30, 2024 from https://abc.net.au/news/2023-03-21/sydney-symphony-conductor-simone-young-knowing-the-score/102034986
Gull, M. (2019). Glass ceiling and women harassment at workplace. Society Publishing.
Hamer, L. (2019). Women on the podium: Issues and strategies of women orchestral conductors. Estudios bandisticos, III, 19-39.
Hernandez, J. C. (n.d.). Top orchestras have no female conductors. Is change coming? Opus 3Artists. Retrieved April 30, 2024, from https://www.opus3artists.com/top-orchestras-have-no-female-conductors-is-change-coming/
Kiek, M.. (2012). Where are all the female musicians? Retrieved May 2, 2024, from http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/classical/features/where-are-all-the-female-musicians-8343938.html
Klenke. K. (1996). Women in leadership: A contextual perspective. Springer Publishing Company.
Lazarou, L. (2016). Women conductors: A qualitative study of gender, family, ‘the body’ and discrimination [PhD dissertation, University of Durham].
Lim, C. (2023, February 6). S’pore female music conductors bridge the gender gap. Retrieved April 30, 2024, from https://tnp.straitstimes.com/lifestyle/others/spore-female-music-conductors-bridge-gender-gap
Morrison, A. M., White, R. P., & Van Velsor, E. (1987). Breaking the glass ceiling: Can women reach the top of America’s largest corporations? Addison-Wesley
Nash, M., Davies, A., & Moore, R. (2017). What style of leadership do women in STEMM fields perform? Findings from an international survey. PLoS ONE, 12(10), e0185727
Royal Philharmonic Society. (2023). Women conductors. Retrieved May 1, 2024, from https://royalphilharmonicsociety.org.uk/performers/women-conductors
Scharff, C. (2018). Gender, subjectivity and cultural work: The classical music profession. Routledge
Sergeant D. C., Himonides, E. (2019). Orchestrated sex: The representation of male and female musicians in world-class symphony orchestras. Frontiers in Psychology 10, 1760. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01760
Singapore Symphony Orchestra. (2024). Our conductors. Retrieved April 30, 2024, from https://www.sso.org.sg/about/singapore-symphony-orchestra/our-conductors
Watson, C. (2023). Cracks in the glass ceiling: women conductors, new trends, old challenges. In R. Mathias (Ed.), The Routledge handbook of women’s work in music (pp. 347-355). Taylor & Francis.
Edward (Player): I feel that, as long as they [women conductors] get the job done… I don't care who is on the podium. As far as they do have results, then I wouldn't mind being conducted by them, but if they don't do the job, then I would have some reservations about that
Tania (Manager):. In terms of management, you know it really depends on the board. Most boards are for me, not diversified enough. For me, diversity comes in many forms. It is not just about gender or race; it is about age as well.
Tania (Manager): I think [in] the recent years, you would see more women in leadership positions, for example, there are many more young women conductors, globally compared with 10 or even 20 years ago.
Sarah (Manager): … maybe they don't really think about being a conductor themself because there's not much training opportunities here, so if you want to be a conductor you go overseas.
Sonia (Manager): … I feel that this gender does not obstruct the progression in my company. Administratively wise. But as in a leadership role musical leadership, we have not seen many or any female positions as a conductor, but we do have female tutors.
Liam (Player): Oh… it's very obvious. Percussion is very male dominated. So currently, I think there's only two females in the section. I think you will see them in tonight’s concert.
Martin (Manager): For percussion ensemble, I currently have about 13 Members and I have two girls, most of them are boys.
Lydia (Manager): A conductor once said to me that they felt I brought ‘an ideal mix of managerial and maternal’ to the role. At the time I found myself deeply offended that ‘maternal’ was mentioned in the context of my professional practice – but the conductor saw my discomfort and clarified that they believe youth organisation leaders need to have the capacity to have warm and authentically respectful relationships with young people in order to do their job well. I do agree with that; and while I still wouldn’t necessarily characterise that as ‘maternal’, whatever it is, the warmth and genuine care is evident in how Tania relates to and supports her players. Affirming to see that Tania also models relationship-building and mentoring as part of her professional role.
Samantha (Manager): A man has told me that I can be aggressive… which is not so... That's about the only thing. you know, and I go. If it was a man…if I were a male, would you have called me aggressive, or such? If it were a man….
It is incumbent on conductors to act as role models and mentors to up-and-coming aspiring women (and men) conductors by providing them with support, building their confidence, and guiding their leadership development necessary to be successful on the podium. As conductors are the artistic leaders within an ensemble, the way they interact with, respond to, and communicate with aspiring conductors, players and managers sends a clear signal as to their values, attitudes, and conscious as well as any unconscious gender-based or other-based biases.
Players are acutely aware that instrument selection is gendered in an orchestra/ensemble while excellence in performance is not in any way connected to gender (or race, age, or any other dimension). As informal and formal leaders within their sections, players should be encouraged to appreciate and support fellow players who may be first-time orchestral players, who may have had different musical experiences and opportunities, and who may be of a different gender or ethnicity. Being sensitive and open to others and getting along with them are essential skills when working in an orchestra.
Managers are key persons within a youth orchestra/ensemble as they, in collaboration with conductors, tutors, and others, play a key role in creating an environment that promotes not only high standards and high expectations, but also support, encouragement, and nurturance for young players. Like conductors managers are role models who set an example for players of what appropriate behaviour and conduct look like. They have within their power, the opportunity to encourage and promote the leadership abilities of both male and female players.