Key words and phrases that informed the development of this dimension include: empower, mistakes, perfect, improve, trigger, safe place, and trust. This dimension includes how participant groups speak about the ways in which an ensemble can be supportive of diverse people and skills, all of which contribute to organisational health. Musicians spoke about their relationship to the organisation and conductors / managers, often recalling situations where they felt well supported. For managers and conductors this dimension was about how they support musicians through their pedagogic practices, but was also sometimes about their own previous negative learning experiences and wanting to ensure musician safety now. The three components are a hierarchy; however, due to the nature of the dimensions, most components also relate symbiotically to one another.
This dimension has three components:
Benefits of being in a youth music ensemble
The positive benefits conferred by active engagement with the arts at all life stages are widely recognised and increasingly being embedded in public health and educational policy, particularly in the United Kingdom. Whilst our world has become more ‘connected’ through technology, issues of social isolation for example persist, with rural and regional young people’s wellbeing and resilience becoming a serious concern for researchers (Houghton et al., 2016; Noble-Carr, et al., 2014). Participation in youth orchestras offers unique opportunities for young people to develop social networks and employability skills such as creativity, collaboration, communication, and critical thinking (Baker et al., 2020; Baker et al., 2022; Jefferson & Anderson, 2017). The most widely publicised programs of orchestral playing for youth are associated with the El Sistema movement, focussed on addressing social inequity through sponsorship, specialised training and role models. El Sistema programs have had a life altering effect on many young people worldwide (Majno 2012), providing musical and non-musical skills leading to increased opportunities in later life (see also Baker et al., 2020).
Increased stress levels and mental health issues have a noticeable impact on adolescent health (Cohen & Cohen 2013) and recent research is indicating that active music making in a group setting can assist in ameliorating stress and promoting mental health and wellbeing for young people (Hewitt &Allan, 2012; Kreutz & Bonshor, 2022; Rodgers & Vargarigou, 2016). As well as musical training, youth orchestras can provide a community of support for adolescents that promotes resilience, but students report that the role of group dynamics in shaping that engagement experience, whether in rehearsal or performance situations, is very important and linked to how they feel about the experience and themselves (Monkhouse & Forbes 2017). In measuring the perceptions of primary and secondary students of their orchestral experience, in community and school-based programs, using a devised Orchestra Meaning Scale, King found that the most positive responses were in the areas of music learning, but also identified the contribution to other non-musical skills (King 2014). Musical benefits are likely to be foregrounded in responses to perceived value of music making activities, but other researchers have also identified, using different survey tools, that young people also perceive a range of social benefits as an outcome of their participation (Kokotsaki & Hallam 2007, 2011).
According to Rustamov et al. (2023) wellbeing encompasses qualities such as ‘Happiness, high life satisfaction, purposefulness, social connections, and the ability to manage stress’ (n.p.). Mental health refers to how people are able to function socially, emotionally, and psychologically, while social connectedness is related to a sense of belonging and involves socialisation and social support (Rustamov et al. 2023). Key contributors to wellbeing include both mental health and social connectedness. Music can be a powerful way to contribute to and support children’s wellbeing, and McArton and Mantie (2023) directly refer to ‘the implicit benevolence of musical participation’ (p. 53). A study by Robb et al. (2023) examined the impact of an after-school music program run for primary-aged children living in a low SES area in Scotland that was held before and during the COVID pandemic. Based on data collected, these researchers concluded that the program supported children’s wellbeing by providing both ‘continuity and stability’ in addition to ‘creating a sense of community’ (p. 15). Wellbeing and resilience may be conceived of as inter-connected concepts (Rustamov et al. 2023), and participation in youth music ensembles provides opportunities for children to develop the traits that contribute to resilience as a part of a mutually supportive learning ecology (Baker et al., 2022b).
Baker, W. J., Forbes, A-M., & Earle, J. (2020). Youth orchestra participation and perceived benefit: A pilot study of Tasmanian Youth Orchestras. Australian Journal of Music Education, 53(1), 3-16.
Baker, W., Forbes, A-M., McLeod, K., & Hunter, M. A. (2022). The music and resilience project.
Baker, W., Forbes, A-M., & McLeod, K. (2022b). If you want your child to be more resilient, get them to join a choir, orchestra or band. - The Conversation.
Cohen, P., & Cohen, J. (2013). Life values and adolescent mental health. Psychology Press.
Hewitt, A., & Allan, A. (2012), Advanced youth music ensembles: Experiences of, and reasons for, participation. International Journal of Music Education, 31(3), 257-275. https://doi.org./10.1177/0255761411434494
Houghton, S., Hattie, J., Carroll, A., Wood, L., & Baffour, B. (2016). It hurts to be lonely! Loneliness and positive mental wellbeing in Australian rural and urban adolescents. Journal of Psychologists and Counsellors in Schools, 26(1), 52-67. https://doi.org/10.1017/jgc.2016.1
Jefferson, M., & Anderson, M. (2017). Transforming schools: Creativity, critical reflection, communication, collaboration. Bloomsbury.
King, K, (2014). Grade 6-12 string performers' perceived meaning of school and community youth orchestra experience [Unpublished PhD dissertation]. Auburn University, Alabama.
Kokotsaki, D., & Hallam, S., (2007). Higher education music students’ perceptions of the benefits of participative music making. Music Education Research, 9(1), 93-109. https://doi.org/10.1080/14613800601127577
Kokotsaki, D., & Hallam, S. (2011) The perceived benefits of participative music making for non-music university students: A comparison with music students. Music Education Research, 13(2), 149-172. https://doi.org/10.1080/14613808.2011.577768
Kreutz, G., & Bonshor, M. (2022). Ensembles for wellbeing. In R. Timmers, F. Bailes and H. Daffern (Eds.), Together in music: Coordination, expression, participation (pp. 191-199). Oxford University Press.
McArton, L., & Mantie, R. (2023). Music, health and well-being in IJCM articles: An integrative review. International Journal of Community Music, 16(1), pp. 51-81. https://doi.org/10.1386/ijcm_00075_1
Majno, M. (2012). From the model of El Sistema in Venezuela to current applications: Learning and integration through collective music education. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1252, 56-64.
Monkhouse, H., & Forbes, A. (2017). Perceptions of tertiary music students on the benefits of ensemble activities. IICE October Proceedings. https://doi.org/10.2053/IICE.2017.0136
Noble-Carr, D., Barker J., McArthur, M., & Woodman, E. (2014). Improving practice: The importance of connections in establishing positive identity and meaning in the lives of vulnerable young people. Children and Youth Services Review, 47(3), 389-396.
Robb, A., Jindal-Snape, D., Asi, D., Barrable, A., Ross, E., Austin, H., & Murray, C. (2023). Supporting children’s well-being through music participation during the COVID-19 pandemic: Evidence from Scotland, Education, 3(13), 1-18. https://doi.org/10.1080/03004279.2023.2219271
Rodgers, D., & Varvarigou, M. (2016). Theme three: Interdisciplinary insights mental health and wellbeing through active music making: The Me2/Orchestra. ISME Proceedings Innovation and Change in Community Music, 89.
Rustamov, E., Musayeva, T., Xalilova, X., Ismayilova, G., & Nahmatova, U. (2023). Exploring the relationships between social connectedness and mental well-being: The mediating role of psychological resilience among adults in Azerbaijan. Discover Psychology, 3(15). https://doi.org/10.1007/s44202-023-00080-8
Kyle (Conductor): I think, student wellbeing just has to be the forefront of everything…. And I think that if people feel really safe and supported, then they are going to play at their absolute best, they're going to feel comfortable to take risks. They're not going to be frightened to play out. So, I think it's really critical, and I think that the world is kind of catching up to that as well. I think gone are the days now where conductors can really get away with you know, behaving really mean spiritedly.
Kyle (Conductor): … I just really like to create a really safe space where it's a shared experience. I'm not really tyrannical in any way. I like to think that I encourage the best performance from everyone who's sitting in front of me.
Nichole (Conductor): The way that it brings people together through connection and socializing and giving them a place to express themselves and feel accepted, as well as challenging their minds and being something that's actually really good for their mental health, as well as just being an all-round positive thing for even the audiences to come in and see the level of performances that are coming out of these organizations are really wonderful.
Nichole (Conductor): And I think I also care very much about the atmosphere between conductor and ensemble and accompanist, and making sure that that balance is something that's very effective as an encouraging and accepting atmosphere, where people actually feel that they can trust the conductor, trust the accompanist, and trust one another in the ensemble too, so developing a sense of community is really important.
Paul (Musician): One of the rewarding things is just having this community. Like everyone in the orchestra is like a family, you know. And yeah, a lot of the people in the orchestra I consider like really good friends.
Ryan (Musician): All of the conductors that I've had are all very open to talking to me about my needs kind of thing, especially within the orchestra. Like if I come up to them, going Okay, I've got a problem with this or this is a problem kind of thing, they will be very open to either talking to you about it or going like, okay, let's work on a solution together, kind of thing. I don't think I've been like turned away, or anything like that before. And so they're all very good at being open and things.
Lydia (Manager): We put a lot of time and effort into ensuring that that development is appropriate. I think that's one of the key points of value of youth orchestras is that, you know, there's the social, there's the emotional, there's a connection, there's the wellbeing, but we also work with them in the moment and at the point of development where they are, and we have the flexibility to do that. That to me is something that's not readily available in a lot of environments.
Laurence (Manager): That you've sort of creating that tribe. And they're there in their tribe, and they can feel safe and feel like they're…part of the crew…. So I think social aspects are huge.
Nichole (Conductor): … you can actually make the two exist together [high performance and wellbeing], if you have a really good expectation around the high performance being something that is artistic and expressive and beautiful and positive, even if it is not perfect. You still want to prepare in such a way that you can hopefully get as close to perfect as possible performance, but it's still much more exciting to do something that you're proud of, and that you feel like you've achieved than thinking, what if or....
Kyle (Conductor): I actually think that the highest level of performance is borne out of well-being, and people feeling that you trust them, and that they're part of something, and that they have some autonomy in what they're doing, that they're part of a bigger team and a collective, and that there's great joy in creating music together.
Nichole (Conductor): … when you're doing something because of others, it does have greater sense of pull, and discipline, I suppose, to actually show up to rehearsals, and then do your part because you can't let the team down. You have to make sure that your parts are learned ready so that you can make this combined sound that's really important.
Frances (Musician): … at the end of the day, I always try to tell myself, hey, this [is a] youth orchestra comprised of young and inexperienced musicians such as yourself, and it's okay, like people make mistakes, or aren't really sure what they're doing, because the whole point of going to a youth orchestra is to is to learn more.
Frances (Musician): … sometimes when I'm in a bad mood, or when I don't have much confidence in myself, it's very easy to compare myself to the younger yet more experienced musicians, and then think [to] myself, do I actually deserve to be here? Am I actually doing as well as I think I'm doing, it's like that. That's the more individual obstacle that I need to overcome.
Laurence (Manager): I feel strongly to be involved and sort of help the next generation of students come through. And as well, to help them realize that they can do amazing things, with the support around them. And I think really, that's what I love empowering kids and getting them to come up with their own ideas and answers.
David (Conductor): I always say before a concert to everybody I try to convey this feeling that everybody's going to have a feeling of anticipation for a concert, otherwise, you wouldn't be human. But it's really a question of how you channel that energy…so that if there are blips, people don't think it's of the utmost importance.
Kyle (Conductor): I've had teachers in the past who have really damaged me, and I've had to work really hard to kind of overcome that, as probably so many students that probably studied during that particular time, maybe the eighties and nineties where there was this kind of generational thing of you know, do this, or else.
Frances (Musician): … at the end of the day, I always try to tell myself, hey, this youth orchestra [is] comprised of young and inexperienced musicians such as yourself, and it's okay, like people make mistakes, or aren't really sure what they're doing, because the whole point of going to a youth orchestra is to learn more.
Ryan (Musician): … the most rewarding bit of it is coming out of the concert and going, Okay, I think I can do that better, but I think that was a pretty good go. And I think having that feeling of working, having worked well with the rest of the orchestra, and my own playing being at a satisfactory level, that I want it to be at….
Paul (Musician): … I study with a lot of people in the orchestra as well. So it's kind of like this, we push each other…in the orchestra to always be better musicians. And I find that it's just so rewarding to have that level of achievement at each stage we go through. You know, we're always improving together. And that, that always feels great. Yeah.
Laurence (Manager): I think my role as a tutor ultimately I take a facilitative role, I'm not a dictator, I don't crack the whip…I think it's about getting the students working together, and not reliant on me. I'm there to guide, but they're not there needing me. They have to become self-sufficient and self-determined….
Lydia (Manager): … there is that balance between challenge and nurture, which is quite hard to manage in high performance environments.
Lydia (Manager): … we are very careful to keep language growth oriented, within the orchestra and not be too hard on mistakes. However, youth orchestras are high-performance environments
Learning environment atmosphere and musician agency are everything. Creating a safe, mutually trusting rehearsal space focussed on musician wellbeing is essential to musician health and wellbeing. High performance expectations and musician wellbeing can exist harmoniously and simultaneously, and this is the result of pedagogic decisions made by the conductor. Growth mindset teaching and learning is a key component for conductors, not stigmatising mistakes, making learning about being open to mistakes and learning from them. It is about re-imagining perfectionism for your ensembles.
Musicians value a sense of community or family, and the opportunity to share their experiences and challenges with conductors. Teaching and learning for growth mindset enables musicians to reframe and overcome challenges in positive and affirming ways. Musicians should be encouraged to consider errors as a part of a continual process of improvement rather than as a deficit.
Explicitly acknowledging to all your stakeholders the multifaceted nature of the learning that occurs in your organisation, such as social and emotional learning as well as musical learning is important to developing healthy organisation wide attitudes and values. Creating a sense of ‘tribe’ amongst musicians is a valuable and vital aspect of effective leadership as is sharing your expertise and motivations for working in your youth music organisation. Managers work alongside conductors to create an environment that balances pedagogy between challenge and nurture, perhaps through growth mindset language.