Summary of this dimension

Key words and phrases that informed the development of this dimension include: empower, mistakes, perfect, improve, trigger, safe place, and trust. This dimension includes how participant groups speak about the ways in which an ensemble can be supportive of diverse people and skills, all of which contribute to organisational health. Musicians spoke about their relationship to the organisation and conductors / managers, often recalling situations where they felt well supported. For managers and conductors this dimension was about how they support musicians through their pedagogic practices, but was also sometimes about their own previous negative learning experiences and wanting to ensure musician safety now. The three components are a hierarchy; however, due to the nature of the dimensions, most components also relate symbiotically to one another.

This dimension has three components:

Positioning our dimension

Benefits of being in a youth music ensemble

The positive benefits conferred by active engagement with the arts at all life stages are widely recognised and increasingly being embedded in public health and educational policy, particularly in the United Kingdom. Whilst our world has become more ‘connected’ through technology, issues of social isolation for example persist, with rural and regional young people’s wellbeing and resilience becoming a serious concern for researchers (Houghton et al., 2016; Noble-Carr, et al., 2014). Participation in youth orchestras offers unique opportunities for young people to develop social networks and employability skills such as creativity, collaboration, communication, and critical thinking (Baker et al., 2020; Baker et al., 2022; Jefferson & Anderson, 2017). The most widely publicised programs of orchestral playing for youth are associated with the El Sistema movement, focussed on addressing social inequity through sponsorship, specialised training and role models. El Sistema programs have had a life altering effect on many young people worldwide (Majno 2012), providing musical and non-musical skills leading to increased opportunities in later life (see also Baker et al., 2020).

Increased stress levels and mental health issues have a noticeable impact on adolescent health (Cohen & Cohen 2013) and recent research is indicating that active music making in a group setting can assist in ameliorating stress and promoting mental health and wellbeing for young people (Hewitt &Allan, 2012; Kreutz & Bonshor, 2022; Rodgers & Vargarigou, 2016). As well as musical training, youth orchestras can provide a community of support for adolescents that promotes resilience, but students report that the role of group dynamics in shaping that engagement experience, whether in rehearsal or performance situations, is very important and linked to how they feel about the experience and themselves (Monkhouse & Forbes 2017). In measuring the perceptions of primary and secondary students of their orchestral experience, in community and school-based programs, using a devised Orchestra Meaning Scale, King found that the most positive responses were in the areas of music learning, but also identified the contribution to other non-musical skills (King 2014). Musical benefits are likely to be foregrounded in responses to perceived value of music making activities, but other researchers have also identified, using different survey tools, that young people also perceive a range of social benefits as an outcome of their participation (Kokotsaki & Hallam 2007, 2011).

According to Rustamov et al. (2023) wellbeing encompasses qualities such as ‘Happiness, high life satisfaction, purposefulness, social connections, and the ability to manage stress’ (n.p.). Mental health refers to how people are able to function socially, emotionally, and psychologically, while social connectedness is related to a sense of belonging and involves socialisation and social support (Rustamov et al. 2023). Key contributors to wellbeing include both mental health and social connectedness. Music can be a powerful way to contribute to and support children’s wellbeing, and McArton and Mantie (2023) directly refer to ‘the implicit benevolence of musical participation’ (p. 53). A study by Robb et al. (2023) examined the impact of an after-school music program run for primary-aged children living in a low SES area in Scotland that was held before and during the COVID pandemic. Based on data collected, these researchers concluded that the program supported children’s wellbeing by providing both ‘continuity and stability’ in addition to ‘creating a sense of community’ (p. 15). Wellbeing and resilience may be conceived of as inter-connected concepts (Rustamov et al. 2023), and participation in youth music ensembles provides opportunities for children to develop the traits that contribute to resilience as a part of a mutually supportive learning ecology (Baker et al., 2022b).

What our participants said

What does this dimension mean for me?

Conductors

Learning environment atmosphere and musician agency are everything. Creating a safe, mutually trusting rehearsal space focussed on musician wellbeing is essential to musician health and wellbeing. High performance expectations and musician wellbeing can exist harmoniously and simultaneously, and this is the result of pedagogic decisions made by the conductor. Growth mindset teaching and learning is a key component for conductors, not stigmatising mistakes, making learning about being open to mistakes and learning from them. It is about re-imagining perfectionism for your ensembles.

Musicians

Musicians value a sense of community or family, and the opportunity to share their experiences and challenges with conductors. Teaching and learning for growth mindset enables musicians to reframe and overcome challenges in positive and affirming ways. Musicians should be encouraged to consider errors as a part of a continual process of improvement rather than as a deficit.

Managers

Explicitly acknowledging to all your stakeholders the multifaceted nature of the learning that occurs in your organisation, such as social and emotional learning as well as musical learning is important to developing healthy organisation wide attitudes and values. Creating a sense of ‘tribe’ amongst musicians is a valuable and vital aspect of effective leadership as is sharing your expertise and motivations for working in your youth music organisation. Managers work alongside conductors to create an environment that balances pedagogy between challenge and nurture, perhaps through growth mindset language.