Key words and phrases that informed the development of this dimension include: pedagogy, discipline, how to rehearse, experience, pressure, and mistakes. This dimension includes participant commentary around the six contributing components. These come from across the three participants groups (musicians, conductors, managers); but do not always come from both participating organisations. The six components are a hierarchy; however, due to the nature of the dimensions most components also affect other components.
This dimension has six components:
High quality performance in a youth music ensemble
High quality performance is a complex, muti-faceted outcome for a musical ensemble, with many contributing factors. For any ensemble, whether professional or amateur, youth or adult, high quality performance is a key objective that produces constant challenges for conductors and musicians. However, youth music ensembles bring with them additional challenges in this environment, such as the challenge of still mastering instrumental and artistic techniques and understandings, blending individual sounds with sections and the ensemble, and working collaboratively and intentionally under the guidance of the conductor, often simultaneously interpreting non-verbal and intuitive cues. These many challenges can be a demanding for professionals, let alone for young developing players at a time of rapid cognitive and emotional development. High quality performance in a youth music ensemble therefore requires the development of high level competencies involving intrapersonal, interpersonal, cognitive and emotional domains (Baker et al., 2022).
Bathurst and Williams (2013) cite three “musical competencies” that are essential for a quality orchestral performance: (1) “Musicianship”, the individual’s mastery of their instrument, (2) “Ensemble (Teamwork)” the group process , and (3) the “Conductor-Musician Relationship” (pp. 42-44). Because musical ensemble is essentially a group of musicians working collaboratively to realise an artistic vision, the ways in which they interact, listen, and play together is critical to high quality performance outcomes. Even though there is a hierarchy in an orchestra led by a conductor who helps to clarify each person’s role and what they must do, to be part of an orchestra is a highly relational activity (Koivunen 2003; Koivunen & Wennes, 2011) that demands respect for the individuality of each contributing voice to the “living organism” (Bibu et al., 2018, p. 507) that is the ensemble (Barenboim, 2009). In an educational context such as a youth music ensemble Baker and King (2013) posit the role of a conductor as that of a conductor-music educator or CME. They write that “Fundamentally a CME never stops teaching and during rehearsals they engage players’ fingers (technique) and musicianship (cognition) through the planning and implementation of meaningful experiences, empowering players to learn” (Baker & King 2013, p. 23).
Baker, W., Forbes, A-M., McLeod, K., & Hunter, M.A. (2022). The music and resilience project. https://www.utas.edu.au/research/projects/music-resilience-project
Baker, W., & King, S. (2013). Redefining the conductor as conductor-music educator. In B. Merrick & D. Forrest (Eds.), Redefining the musical landscape: Inspired learning and innovation in music education. Proceedings of the XIX National ASME conference. Australian Society for Music Education, Parkville.
Barenboim, D. (2009). Everything is connected: The power of music. Phoenix.
Bathurst, R.J., & Williams, L.P. (2013). Managing musically: How acoustic space informs management practice. Journal of Management Inquiry, 22(1), 38-49. https://doi.org.10.1177/1056492612464543
Bibu, N., Brancu, L., & Teohari, G. A. (2018). Managing a symphony orchestra in times of change: Behind the curtains. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 238, 507-516.
Koivunen, N. (2003). Leadership in symphony orchestras: Discursive and aesthetic practices. Tampere University Press.
Koivunen, N., & Wennes, G. (2011). Show us the sound! Aesthetic leadership of symphony orchestra conductors. Leadership, 7(1), 51-71. https://org.au/10.1177/1742715010386865
Kyle (Conductor): I actually think that the highest level of performance is born out of well-being, and people feeling that you trust them, and that they're part of something, and that they have some autonomy in what they're doing, that they're part of a bigger team and a collective, and that there's great joy in creating music together.
Kent (Conductor): …with a youth orchestra our kids are not at the professional performing level yet, quite often they fail to see the bigger picture… it's what the youth orchestra needs at that point of time. What do they need? So, for me, approaching a youth orchestra is very different from when I'm conducting or programming for a professional orchestra, it's a totally different ball game. Rehearsal technique is quite different as well…I find that this is completely different.
Nichole (Conductor): … it's really important that performance needs to become normalized and not necessarily built up to be this big, high stakes, high pressure situation. It needs to be something that we do because we love music and we share music.
Frances (Musician) …the first challenge, I would say is learning new repertoire quite fast. I don't think it's very fast as in professional standards fast, but fast enough… I remember being really stressed out before placement auditions. Because some of the repertoire that we tackle is not just a technical challenge, but it's also a musicianship challenge.
Liam (Musician): I think the most rewarding for me is…playing all this great music, because I don't think anywhere else I will be able to play these kinds of music. Especially with how music is run in schools.
Tania (Manager): I always tell people we don't take the best musicians; we make the best musicians out of the musicians who are passionate about classical music.
Lydia (Manager): One of the things that we say all the time…is that we work with the kids that we have, not with a theoretical model of youth orchestra kids
Kent (Conductor): A lot of conductors had told me that in order to be a good conductor you need to have had working experience within an orchestra as a musician, so you know what to do and what not to do… I really, really wanted to do something for the youth orchestra, and I thought my experience was quite unique.
Kyle (Conductor): I did national youth orchestra as well as playing in the Uni orchestras and then finishing that, I freelanced for a couple of years as a performer…I did a 6-month contract touring with a national opera company over 2 years before deciding that I was enjoying the teaching aspects of all of that more than the performance. So, I ended up enrolling into a Graduate Diploma of Education.
Ryan (Musician): So I am a second year university student. I am studying a degree of classical music majoring in French Horn performance. Yeah, I'm looking to continuing on that orchestral path, and so the TYO is a big part of that.
Frances (Musician): I've been playing the cello since I was six years old, but it's only when I was 16 that I decided to join the orchestra, because I got serious about music then.
Tania (Manager): I think it is fundamental for the youth orchestra manager to have a strong background in music and with an orchestral background. In addition, it is almost a necessity to have both depth and breadth of experience (or pick up some of these skills along the way) because most of the time the youth orchestra team will be lean and the manager in all likelihood needs to cover the gaps, of which there are many!
Vicky (Manager): … I'm an orchestra musician of many years, almost three decades. And then, just recently, so last year, really, decided to try and make a transition into administration, arts administration… my experience so far is that it's definitely a massive advantage.
Frances (Musician): … because I want to pursue music professionally, it's a very good platform, because the orchestra’s style of rehearsal is quite professional. There's a high standard too so it feels like I'm really spending my time wisely and learning many things. And that's rewarding.
Ryan (Musician): So I am a second year university student. I am studying a degree of classical music majoring in French Horn performance. Yeah, I'm looking to continuing on that orchestral path, and so the orchestra is a big part of that.
Paul (Musician): I study with a lot of people in the orchestra as well. So it's kind of like this, we push each other at the con and in the orchestra to always be better musicians. And I find that it's just so rewarding to have that level of achievement at each stage we go through. You know, we're always improving together. And that, that always feels great.
Vicky (Manager): … we're aware that it's not a big team, but you just still have to get it done. It just has to get done. And so, you know, people work extremely long hours at times, and have ridiculously long weeks that turn into fortnights and months, and probably in Lydia's case, years, of just working stupid hours to be able to make that work.
Martin (Manager): I think the good thing about the orchestra is that the students are very high ability, so they function like a well-oiled machine. We are very used to routines so, for example, things like we hardly have people forgetting their scores, and things that they're all on time…. I think for the orchestra, the intention of the members in to why they are here, is very clear. So, they're very goal driven. They want to be here.
Kyle (Conductor): … my experience is that they [managers] do everything to make sure that I can just walk in and do my job and be in that moment without having to worry about the niggly things.
Nichole (Conductor): So it's a wonderful connection to have, somebody who is managing everything and organizing things like venues and concert dates, and so on. And so the opportunity to just be in an artistic and creative world where I'm able to work hands on with the singers and program the actual music.
Kent (Conductor): … thankfully, we have a very good management as well, so I don't have to deal with all these issues. There is basically a separation of responsibilities…. It's a very, very well defined role.
Paul (Musician): … having these conductors and all the staff members at the orchestra sending these emails out on ways, and things to practice on exactly, it let’s us set a goal and an objective that we can practice throughout the week and then come back with this feeling of success….
Samantha (Manager): And then a good part of my work will also entail chorister and parent management. Yes, parent management is a big part of that, because well, I've got 180 kids, you know, I obviously my work is not only managing, it's managing the parents as well, and of course, all the inquiries that come in.
Frances (Musician): Currently, I'm waiting to go to conservatory because I applied to the Royal Northern College of Music and that term only starts in September. So now I'm interning at the orchestra and doing projects there. Also just like, I'm just trying my best to play as much in groups as possible, to gain experience and stuff.
Liam (Musician): Because I love performing music so much with the orchestra that I wanted to maybe try to make a career out of it.
Tania (Manager): … it gets more and more difficult to get into the orchestra when they are in their teens, simply because our standards are really high, which is a shame because we have many good talented young violinists. The standard is so high, it is impossible (to get in), I never played like that, when I was their age.
Lydia (Manager): One of the things that we say all the time in the orchestra is that we work with the kids that we have, not with a theoretical model of youth orchestra kids… One of the first things I did was sit down with the artistic leads, and we did a six month review of the ensemble structure because it was clear that it was not working for the orchestra, and that was because it was based on having a waitlist of 300 kids and having this incredible population density of young classical musicians. We don't have that, so we needed to restructure to work with the kids that we have, and the environment we're in, not with some theoretical model.
Kyle (Conductor): And then I also rehearsed them for an upcoming program that they're doing. It's called the Big Rehearsal, where they'll work with professional orchestra and work on particular repertoire. So I'll just go along and be part of the audience for that.
Ryan (Musician): I think the other thing is that the orchestra has been really good at making connections within the music community, because so much of the music, especially the classical community, the orchestral community revolves around, bringing out like the newest generation of musicians.
Edward (Musician): There are more limited opportunities back in my school and, as I mentioned just now, there's more chance for more complex, more difficult repertoire. I really like the experience of playing orchestra, in a youth orchestra.
Paul (Musician): … there wasn't much opportunity out in country New South Wales to do that. I had the privilege to play with one other orchestra, but that was just once or twice….
Conductors should understand the criticality of their pedagogic practice in ensuring high standards, whilst simultaneously ensuring musician engagement and safety, along with an understanding of the centrality of their role in selecting achievable yet challenging canon repertoire. Conductors should be mindful that high levels of performance are inextricably linked to wellbeing, and that their extended rehearsal schedules should operationalise a pedagogy that offers musicians long term learning opportunities. Conductors should model a growth mindset approach to performance that minimises the impacts of perfectionism and maximises learning opportunities for their musicians. High levels of experience and expertise are required for conductors both as musicians and educators. Conductors should be cognisant of the need to work collaboratively with managers acknowledging the value of both roles in the achievement of an artistic vision.
Musicians clearly value the qualitative difference between school based ensembles and those of the youth music organisation, along with the challenge of performing canon repertoire, and the professionalism of the youth music organisation conductor. Musicians value safe challenge in a professional learning environment akin to that of a musical family, and in which other musicians are similarly motivated. Musicians value multiple different opportunities to expand their musical understandings and networks and enjoy working with other like-minded musicians. For some of the musicians interested in a future career as a musician, being part of a youth orchestra provides fundamental training.
Managers must have musical expertise and a musical background in order to best assist the organisation to achieve its artistic vision. They should have a sophisticated understanding of the environment in which they work and from which they draw musicians, ensuring that the organisation is best placed to serve the needs of those musicians. Managers reinforce organisational and conductor visions for high quality outcomes in harmony with musician wellbeing and maintain high standards around expectations. Negotiating a range of experiences and opportunities for musicians designed to develop the breadth of their learning experience in both formal and informal ways is an important role for managers. Developing a list of potential group participants is an important component of the managerial role, to ensure that potential ‘gaps’ in instrumentation are always front of mind, and programs to address these gaps developed. Ensuring that organisational systems and culture maximise the collaborative possibilities between conductors and themselves is also a key leadership role for managers.