Go to Home

Governing during an ocean climate crisis: Building integrative capacity

This project is funded by Australian Research Council Grant-Discovery Projects.

The world’s oceans are in crisis. Climate change and increasing human impacts are creating new policy and governance challenges for governments around the world. However, current siloed, sector-based management approaches, policies and institutional arrangements are failing to address significant and urgent problems, including rising sea levels, acidification, marine pollution, changes to species distribution, productivity and abundance.

A proposed solution to confront this crisis is integrated oceans management (IOM), which supports marine ecosystem sustainability through holistic and knowledge-based approaches. This project expects to identify new and innovative approaches to implement IOM by identifying which components of integrative capacity can be improved.

Our key questions:

Why does IOM work in some cases and not in others?

How can integrative capacity be improved to enable governments, stakeholders, Indigenous groups and communities to transition to effective, sustainable and successful IOM?

About our project

This project aims to investigate how strengthening the integrative capacity of governments, public institutions, marine sectors, Indigenous groups and communities will lead to improved integrated oceans management (IOM).  It will enhance oceans governance and benefit countries' efforts to mitigate climate change impacts on the marine environment.

Recognising that this crisis facing our oceans is largely a consequence of a failure of governance, the United Nations has called for ‘an integrated, interdisciplinary and cross-sectoral approach as well as enhanced cooperation, coordination, and policy coherence, at all levels’ in oceans governance (Res 71/312 of 6 July 2017). However, merely calling for integrated approaches will not overcome siloed arrangements or cultures and will ring hollow if they are not accompanied by specific, feasible, and effective pathways to implementation. Incremental methods currently used to achieve policy change are not enough. Scientific modelling approaches are used and steer decision-making processes (without political implications/considerations). Institutional rearrangement and innovation in policy design is required to achieve integration. Specifically, the critical gap in achieving successful implementation of IOM is the lack of integrative capacity within governments and their institutions.

Integrative capacity is the ability of government agencies to collaborate vertically and horizontally across sectors and jurisdictions and with stakeholders, Indigenous groups and communities, while being supported by an appropriate organisational architecture, legislative arrangements and political will.

This project will identify which components of integrative capacity can be improved and provide practical steps governments, industry and civil society stakeholders, Indigenous groups, and communities can use to build integrative capacity to implement IOM in Australia and Canada.

Aerial view of waves breaking with swirls of white, greens and blue

The project aims are:

  • Evaluate integrative capacity through comparative case studies of IOM in Australia and Canada, to understand which factors facilitate or hinder the implementation of IOM;
  • Evaluate which components of integrative capacity can be modelled and included in structured decision-support tools and identify which components remain specifically political processes;
  • Map steps and strategies to build integrative capacity and strengthen governance and the transition to IOM based on our findings.

Research outputs

An important aspect of policy integration is the need for policymakers to establish integrative capacity. However, what integrative capacity is and what aspects of the policy process policymakers need to focus on to establish that capacity has not been explained in the literature.

We define integrative capacity and introduce an “integrative capacity framework” (Vince et al., 2024) that outlines key components required by public agencies to progress policy integration.

We argue that by unpacking the integrative capacity concept, scholars and policymakers can utilize the framework to identify what elements of the policy process need to be addressed to increase the likelihood of integrative policy success. In our project we apply our integrative capacity framework to Australian and Canadian case studies. The outcomes of our project can be found in the following publications and reports.

Understanding policy integration through an integrative capacity framework

Publications and reports

PhD candidates

  • Kathryn Deyell
  • Renée Melkert

Contact

If you are interested in getting in touch, please contact Associate Professor Joanna Vince.