Go to Home

Think why and how

Careful, critical reflection and reasoning underpin the process of independent and informed decision making.

Introduction

What our participants said

“I'm very well aware that, okay, there's a number of students here, they have a, probably a lower engagement…they can be distracted easily. How can I engage them? So? I guess I'm always thinking about that engagement.” (Timothy, Conductor)

“So, my challenge was, okay, how can I share with them an effective system of practice ? I will need to choose good repertoire because if I don't choose significant repertoire, then there is no point learning the stuff.  Besides, good repertoire choice inspires personal practice investment!” (Nicholas, Conductor)

“So, what I wanted to do was to help them with the challenge of fear. Fear of failure, fear of rejection…So, that meant that every rehearsal had to be filled, first of all with encouragement, and secondly with engaging activities and thirdly, lots of playing opportunities. It's hard enough to play these instruments, let alone to have somebody who is demanding the unending demands.” (Nicholas, Conductor)

“What I found a useful technique...is to immediately identify from the score which parts are playing the same material together. And immediately after a playthrough to say, ‘Let’s look at this, these three parts which are playing together’...because people start to think, ‘Oh right, yes that’s right.’”

“What we ended up deciding on was putting them into the younger ensemble just for a few weeks to get their confidence going, and to do a concert and then move them up to the next ensemble following that, while making sure that they had a bit of support in that position by partnering them with someone … and also for the conductor to be aware of that player and just to check in with them to see how they're going and things like that. So that's that was an interesting situation.” (Ben, Conductor)

Exemplar

One of the ensemble leaders, Nicholas, talked specifically about modelling a process of analysis, critical reflection and strategic practice in rehearsals that would underpin a transferrable process for individual critical practising.  The process he used was highly targeted, with clear intended outcomes that were easy to comprehend and measure. Efficiency was a prized attribute of the process, in both the expenditure of effort and time. Players could easily identify if the outcome of their efforts was successful, and the application of this process encouraged the development of skills in close critical reflection, thinking about what adjustments should be made and further reflection on the outcome. In his own words: “I wanted the students to receive a proforma of learning how to practice, for I believe that every rehearsal, every private lesson is actually a lesson in how to practice at home. I want to teach you how to do this, I want to teach you how to invest, we call that practice… What I was teaching them was comparative repetition. You can't escape the fact that it is time on task. But how can you do it well?  Isolate the details, repeat, isolate the details repeat. We isolated the one bar, they didn't need to practice from the top to the bottom. That's, inefficient, dumb practice. Smart practice, is you lift out the offending bar or the offending rhythm, you apply a counting system to it, or you apply a slow process of fingering. Then, you've got it mastered.   We did this in rehearsal several times…In five minutes, we had mastery. Would you want to do that at home?  Yeah!...We need to teach ‘process’. And it's not process about music. Music is a great platform for teaching kids how to use process.” (Nicholas, conductor).

What does this mean for me?