Go to Home

The community youth music ensemble leadership project

Image credit Mike Morffew

Images supplied and credited to Mike Morffew.

Welcome to our project website. This site is for anyone who conducts youth music ensembles either in schools or in community youth music organisations, however the inclusion of the ‘Manager’ lens on this research foregrounds community youth music ensembles.

Our participant organisations in this research were Tasmanian Youth Orchestras and the Singapore National Youth Orchestra. We sincerely hope that within our research website, you find useful research-based guidance to support conductors, managers and players in this space.

Research project Data collection Our team

Four project dimensions

Reflections on high performance and wellbeing

Associate Professor Anne-Marie Forbes, School of Creative Arts and Media chats with Jack Machin and Mark Bain.

Research

Singapore and Australia are both Asia-Pacific countries, yet their orchestras share a western music tradition. Both countries have highly regarded youth orchestras enabling young musicians to play music at high levels in nurturing environments.

In the State of Tasmania this is Tasmanian Youth Orchestras (TYO), and in Singapore this is the Singapore National Youth Orchestra (SNYO). Orchestral leaders (managers, board members, conductors, players and tutors) create the organisational and educational circumstances in which young musicians can thrive.

This project investigated the perceptions of leaders in both groups, exploring the following research questions:

  1. What are the educational and organisational parameters that foster high quality performance opportunities for young musicians?
  2. What are the educational and organisational parameters that foster healthy, resilient attitudes in young musicians?
  3. What are the circumstances that enable female leaders to rise to prominent roles in youth orchestra leadership?
  4. What are the cultural factors that influence each of these areas?

This research project was funded by a Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) People-to-People Grant (Australia-ASEAN Council Grant # AAC110 value $33,449.90).

The grant included a four day visit to Singapore by representatives from Tasmania Youth Orchestras and University of Tasmania in 2022, and a return visit to Hobart by Singapore National Youth Orchestra representatives in 2023.

Please note that following the University of Tasmania Ethics approval there was considerable disruption to the commencement of this project caused by COVID and international travel bans.

Participating organisations

Data Collection and analysis

This project was conducted as an ethnography (Patton 2015) and collected data through participant vlogs, individual interviews, and focus groups.

The main participants in the study were drawn from SNYO and TYO players, managers, and conductors and tutors, with a total of 19 participants overall: 5 players, 9 managers, and 5 conductors and tutors. All data were collected in line with the UTAS project ethics approval. Data collection took place intermittently over a two-year period, and all transcripts were checked by participants for authenticity and accuracy.

Data were analysed using a rigorous and extensive application of the six-phase reflective Thematic Analysis (TA) approach developed by Braun and Clarke (2022). These six phases analyse data by developing codes and tentative themes before arriving at a fully defensible set of final themes. To assist this process NVivo software, referred to by Braun and Clarke (2022) as computer-assisted qualitative data analysis software or CAQDAS (p. 65), was used to analyse these data.

  • Braun, V. and Clarke. V. (2022), Thematic analysis: A practical guide, [eBook edition], SAGE, accessed 8 July 2023.
  • Patton, M. Q. (2015). Qualitative research & evaluation methods: Integrating theory and practice (4th ed.) [eBook edition]. Sage.

Contact

Please contact Associate Professor Anne-Marie Forbes if you have any queries.